Effects of small hydropower dams on macroinvertebrate and fish assemblages in southern Brazil

Couto, Thiago B. A. and Rezende, Renan S. and de Aquino, Pedro P. U. and Costa‐Pereira, Raul and de Campos, Gelso L. and Occhi, Thiago V. T. and Vitule, Jean R. S. and Espírito‐Santo, Helder M. V. and Soares, Yan F. F. and Olden, Julian D. (2023) Effects of small hydropower dams on macroinvertebrate and fish assemblages in southern Brazil. Freshwater Biology, 68 (6). pp. 956-971. ISSN 0046-5070

Abstract

Hydropower dams affect freshwater biodiversity by virtue of modifying flow regimes and degrading habitat conditions both above and below the water impoundment and diversion structure. In recent decades, there has been a global proliferation of Small Hydropower Plants (SHPs) propelled by incentive policies and a general perception that small dams are less harmful to the environment. However, limited science is available on the effects of SHPs on freshwater biodiversity, which is concerning considering their sheer numbers and the high variability in the size and operation of dams classified as SHPs. We investigated the ecological effects of 12 SHPs on macroinvertebrate and fish assemblages of the Chapecó River Basin, Brazil. Our study included sites located upstream of the SHPs and sites directly affected by their operations (i.e., reservoir, dewatering section and downstream of the powerhouse). This design allowed us to quantify shifts in taxonomic composition and examine the relative role of different SHP attributes (e.g., dam height, reservoir area, age) in explaining these changes. Our results reveal that SHPs modify the composition of both macroinvertebrate and fish assemblages, but the magnitude of such changes vary widely among dams. Both assemblages exhibited directionality in taxonomic shifts, resulting in a gradual replacement of taxa associated with fast-flowing habitats by other groups more commonly associated with standing waters. We also found that changes in assemblage structureare related to structural (dam height, reservoir area) and spatial attributes (distance from headwaters) of SHPs, although the predictive power of these attributes varied taxonomically and among reservoir, dewatering and downstream sites. Overall, our results demonstrate that SHPs have important and heterogeneous effects on freshwater assemblages, which may manifest individually or cumulatively across the riverscape. This suggests that it is unlikely that a priori classifications of dams based on their structural attributes can replace site-specific and cumulative impact assessments. The results also shed light on the need for better understanding of how SHP attributes shape their ecological effects, so that a full assessment of the potential environmental impacts of the wide range of "small" dams is possible.