Literacy Research and Its Relationship with Policy : What and Who Informs Policy and Why Is Some Research Ignored?

Papen, Uta (2023) Literacy Research and Its Relationship with Policy : What and Who Informs Policy and Why Is Some Research Ignored? Research in the Teaching of English, 58 (1): 3. pp. 63-80. ISSN 0034-527X

Text (accepted author manuscript)
Papen.Literacyresearchandrelationshipwithpolicy.revised.docx - Accepted Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.
Download (100kB)

Abstract

Socio-cultural and practice-based approaches to literacy, associated with the (New) Literacy Studies, having emerged in the 1980s, nowadays are an established research field. Based on in-depth research, in many contexts and countries, the (New) Literacy Studies has much to offer to teachers and policymakers. And yet this impressive body of work has had little impact on policy. Taking as my example England, I ask what research has shaped policy in the past 30 years and why socio-cultural and practice-based studies have been ignored. Thus, I address the question of where the field has been and where it should go to from the point of view of its relationship with policy. My focus is on the initial teaching of literacy in primary (elementary) schools. I discuss three factors which I believe contribute to our struggles to influence policy: the policy environment itself and how it has changed; the wider economy of literacy research and what knowledge counts in the interface between research and policy; and, finally, the role of the media and public discourse in the relationship between research and policy. I end with questions about what we may have missed and where the field might want to go.