Politics and the Family:Rethinking the India-Pakistan Two-Nations Theory through the Familial Construction of Political Ideas

Kadir, Jawad and Jawad, Majida (2020) Politics and the Family:Rethinking the India-Pakistan Two-Nations Theory through the Familial Construction of Political Ideas. India Review, 19 (3). pp. 223-253.

Text (INDIAREVIEW-D-19-00027_R1)
INDIAREVIEW_D_19_00027_R1.pdf - Accepted Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial.
Download (3MB)

Abstract

There are very few scholarly endeavours that have focused Pakistan-India partition and their ongoing conflict from an indigenous theoretical lens. A psycho-cultural paradigm has been used in this article to re-examine and reconceptualize the enduring two-Nations theory – a political ideology, which manifests Hindu-Muslim discord in the Indian Subcontinent by construing both communities as distinct nations based on their inherent ethno-religious and civilizational differences. Considering a very complex process of mass conversion, assimilation, and criss-crossing of caste-system between both groups, this article argues that it is theoretically problematic to differentiate between Hindus and Muslims purely on ethno-religious grounds. Given the significant impact of the institution of family on the lives of the Subcontinental people, regardless of their faith – I propose that it can be more explanatory to categorize both groups as competing branches of a joint family, to understand the construction of political ideology of two-Nations theory in familial terms. This article seeks to clarify the theoretical mechanism through which the family-level ideas can shape peoples’ worldview, informing the way they perceive abstract concepts such as group-conflict and the nation, thus impacting their political thoughts.