Moss, Henry and Leslie, David Stuart and Rayson, Paul Edward (2018) Using J-K-fold Cross Validation to Reduce Variance When Tuning NLP Models. In: Proceedings of COLING 2018 :. Proceedings of COLING 2018 . Association for Computational Linguistics (ACL Anthology), USA, 2978–2989.
coling2018.pdf - Accepted Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.
Download (463kB)
Abstract
K-fold cross validation (CV) is a popular method for estimating the true performance of machine learning models, allowing model selection and parameter tuning. However, the very process of CV requires random partitioning of the data and so our performance estimates are in fact stochastic, with variability that can be substantial for natural language processing tasks. We demonstrate that these unstable estimates cannot be relied upon for effective parameter tuning. The resulting tuned parameters are highly sensitive to how our data is partitioned, meaning that we often select sub-optimal parameter choices and have serious reproducibility issues. Instead, we propose to use the less variable J-K-fold CV, in which J independent K-fold cross validations are used to assess performance. Our main contributions are extending J-K-fold CV from performance estimation to parameter tuning and investigating how to choose J and K. We argue that variability is more important than bias for effective tuning and so advocate lower choices of K than are typically seen in the NLP literature, instead use the saved computation to increase J. To demonstrate the generality of our recommendations we investigate a wide range of case-studies: sentiment classification (both general and target-specific), part-of-speech tagging and document classification.