On harm thresholds and living organ donation : must the living donor benefit, on balance, from his donation?

Williams, Nicola Jane (2018) On harm thresholds and living organ donation : must the living donor benefit, on balance, from his donation? Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy, 21 (1). pp. 11-22. ISSN 1386-7423

[thumbnail of On_Harm_Thresholds_and_LOD_JMHP_AMENDED_FINAL]
PDF (On_Harm_Thresholds_and_LOD_JMHP_AMENDED_FINAL)
On_Harm_Thresholds_and_LOD_JMHP_AMENDED_FINAL.pdf - Accepted Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial.

Download (467kB)


For the majority of scholars concerned with the ethics of living organ donation, inflicting moderate harms on competent volunteers in order to save the lives or increase the life chances of others is held to be justifiable provided certain conditions are met. These conditions tend to include one, or more commonly, some combination of the following: 1. The living donor provides valid consent to donation. 2. Living donation produces an overall positive balance of harm-benefit for donors and recipients which cannot be obtained in a less harmful manner. 3. Donation is not liable to cause significant and long-term morbidity to, or the death of, the donor. This paper critically examines the suggestion that these criteria are not sufficient to offer a general account of justified living organ donation in the context of competent volunteers and that key to justified living organ donation is that donors receive sufficient benefits from their donation that these outweigh the harms they suffer. However, although this view – termed here ‘The Donor Benefit Standard’ – directs welcome attention to the many and complex motives which may underlie living organ donation, this paper ultimately concludes that given the threats this position poses to individual autonomy and the lives of those in need of organ transplants ‘The Donor Benefit Standard’ should ultimately be rejected.

Item Type:
Journal Article
Journal or Publication Title:
Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy
Additional Information:
The final publication is available at Springer via http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s11019-017-9778-x
Uncontrolled Keywords:
?? living organ donationtransplantation ethicsautonomybeneficenceharmeducationhealth(social science)health policy ??
ID Code:
Deposited By:
Deposited On:
23 May 2017 12:10
Last Modified:
24 Nov 2023 00:23