Cats and categories – reply to Teubert

Sealey, Alison (2014) Cats and categories – reply to Teubert. Language and Dialogue, 4 (2). 299 – 321. ISSN 2210-4127

Microsoft Word (Cats & categories - reply to Teubert)
Cats_categories_19_01_14.docx - Accepted Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial No Derivatives.
Download (77kB)

Abstract

This paper is a response to the discussion article in Language and Dialogue 3:2 by Wolfgang Teubert, “Was there a cat in the garden? Knowledge between discourse and the monadic self.” Teubert deals there with a number of themes, including a discussion of some philosophical issues raised by Roy Harris and Martin Heidegger. In my response, I am less concerned with those aspects of the article than with the claims made by Teubert about the contrasts between humans and other animals. I respond to Teubert’s position on the status and origins of categories of animals from a realist perspective, with reference to evidence from the natural sciences and anthropology. I suggest that Teubert’s thesis rests on a number of errors, including an over-estimation of the power of discourse, an under-estimation of the range of sensory and semiotic perception available to different kinds of creatures, and a lack of attention to contemporary developments in relevant ethological research.