Strategy-as-Power:Ambiguity, Contradiction and the Exercise of Power in a UK Building Society

McCabe, Darren (2010) Strategy-as-Power:Ambiguity, Contradiction and the Exercise of Power in a UK Building Society. Organization, 17 (2). pp. 151-175. ISSN 1350-5084

Full text not available from this repository.


'Strategy-as-practice (s-a-p) scholars have urged us to attend to the messy realities of strategy so as to increase the relevance of research for practitioners. This article, whilsts recognising the need to focus on what managers do, develops a critique of this literature. It argues that the s-a-p approach (Whittington, Jarzabkowski, Johnson, Balogun) and the earlier 'Power School' (Mintzberg, Pettigrew, Pfeffer) share much in common as both present power as the possession of management. This overstates the ability of managers to control others whilst understating the scope for resistance. Second, it asserts that both approaches would benefit from greater sensitivity towards the unequal context through which strategies emerge and that they serve, in part, to reproduce. Third, the article provides an empirical case study of strategy in a UK Building Society. It attends to how power is exercised in ambiguous and contradictory ways that both supports and thwarts managerial endeavours. Through considering the uncertainty that results from this, the case reflects on the possibilities for resistance. The central argument is that if we explore practice only from management's perspective, then we are in danger of not only reinforcing the status quo but also of being irrelevant to practitioners and wider constituents.

Item Type:
Journal Article
Journal or Publication Title:
Uncontrolled Keywords:
ID Code:
Deposited By:
Deposited On:
10 Jul 2012 10:34
Last Modified:
21 Nov 2022 22:30