Are asset securitizations sales or loans?

Landsman, W R and Peasnell, K V and Shakespeare, C (2008) Are asset securitizations sales or loans? The Accounting Review, 83 (5). pp. 1251-1272. ISSN 0001-4826

[thumbnail of Are asset securitizations sales or loans?]
PDF (Are asset securitizations sales or loans?)
10.pdf - Submitted Version

Download (245kB)


This study addresses whether asset securitizations are really asset sales or a form of secured borrowing, by estimating cross-sectional equity valuation regressions to assess whether the stock market treats securitized assets and liabilities held by a special purpose entity (SPE) as assets and liabilities of the sponsor-originator (S-O). Overall, we find that the market views the SPE assets and liabilities as belonging to the S-O, i.e., the risk and rewards of ownership of the transferred assets reside with the S-O and not the SPE. Results from a boot-strapping simulation that controls for scale by randomly assigning SPE assets and liabilities from one S-O to another provide evidence that scale bias is an unlikely explanation for finding the market views SPE assets and liabilities as belonging to the S-O. Findings from specifications in which we permit coefficients to differ for S-O firms with high and low relative levels of retained interest indicate that whereas the market views asset securitizations by low retained interest S-O firms as sales, i.e., risk transfer has taken place, it views asset securitizations by high retained interest S-O firms as secured borrowings, i.e., risk transfer is incomplete. We also show that although the market views securitizations by regulated and unregulated S-Os as secured borrowing, there is suggestive evidence that regulated firms have greater incentives to use securitizations to achieve off-balance sheet financing.

Item Type:
Journal Article
Journal or Publication Title:
The Accounting Review
Uncontrolled Keywords:
ID Code:
Deposited By:
Deposited On:
11 Jul 2011 18:25
Last Modified:
18 Oct 2023 00:39