Ethical, psychological and social un/certainties in the face of deemed consent for organ donation in England

Machin, Laura and Wrench, Elizabeth and Cooper, Jessie and Dixon, Heather and Wilkinson, Mark (2024) Ethical, psychological and social un/certainties in the face of deemed consent for organ donation in England. Health Care Analysis. ISSN 1065-3058 (In Press)

Text (HCA_Healthcare_Professional_Uncertainties_Main_Text_V2)
HCA_Healthcare_Professional_Uncertainties_Main_Text_V2.pdf - Accepted Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.
Download (366kB)

Abstract

Deemed consent legislation for deceased organ donation was introduced in England in 2020, and is considered a vital part of the new UK NHS Blood and Transplant’s 10-year strategy to increase consent for organ donation. Despite the legislation containing safeguards to protect the public, the introduction of deemed consent creates ethical, psychological and social un/certainties for healthcare professionals in their practice. In this paper, we offer insights into healthcare professionals’ perspectives on deemed consent, drawn from interview data with 24 healthcare professionals in an NHS Trust in England, prior to the introduction of the legislation. Whilst participants supported deemed consent in principle, they were concerned that it would present a threat to the nature of donation as a ‘gift’; the notion of informed consent (or non-consent); and the autonomy of donors, their relatives, and their own roles as health professionals, posing dilemmas for practice. We argue that healthcare professionals present themselves as guardians of potential (non)donors and thus as having ethics and integrity in their own practice. We draw conclusions around the values and principles that matter to healthcare professionals when contemplating consent in deceased donation which will be useful for organ donation committees and ethics forums.