‘BEING A FANGIRL OF A SERIAL KILLER IS NOT OK’:Gatekeeping Reddit’s True Crime Community

Fathallah, Judith (2022) ‘BEING A FANGIRL OF A SERIAL KILLER IS NOT OK’:Gatekeeping Reddit’s True Crime Community. New Media and Society. ISSN 1461-7315

Full text not available from this repository.


All fandoms engage in gatekeeping. Whether or not we agree that contemporary media fandoms comprise something like ‘communities’, the ‘-dom’ suffix to the term ‘fan’ necessitates some conception of a group, and groups have boundaries. These boundaries are always in tension, and self-defined true crime fans are a tricky case. True crime is mainstream, an endlessly profitable and staple of the media landscape. However, true crime fans must negotiate and police a boundary that separates them from the posited figure of the Bad Fan. This article examines the Reddit subforums r/TrueCrime and r/SerialKillers, analysing posts that discuss and police the boundaries separating the right kind of interest in true crime from this posited Bad Fan. I argue that while true crime enthusiasts tend to present their gatekeeping work as an ethical practice, it is often more to do with maintaining gendered norms than it is about morality or propriety.

Item Type:
Journal Article
Journal or Publication Title:
New Media and Society
Uncontrolled Keywords:
ID Code:
Deposited By:
Deposited On:
08 Dec 2022 14:50
Last Modified:
20 Sep 2023 01:56