Introduction: Gender Equity in Abrahamic Circumcision : Why or Why Not?

Bergom Lunde, Ingvild and Johnson, Matthew (2022) Introduction: Gender Equity in Abrahamic Circumcision : Why or Why Not? Global Discourse, 12 (1). pp. 3-7. ISSN 2326-9995

[thumbnail of Introduction Gender Equity in Abrahamic Circumcision Why or Why Not]
Text (Introduction Gender Equity in Abrahamic Circumcision Why or Why Not)
Introduction_Gender_Equity_in_Abrahamic_Circumcision_Why_or_Why_Not.pdf - Accepted Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial.

Download (207kB)


Taking Richard Shweder’s (2021) article ‘The prosecution of Dawoodi Bohra women: some reasonable doubts’ as a target piece for discussion, the aim of this issue is to better understand these limitations. In the article, Shweder proposes that some forms of FGC be legalized, arguing that the form of FGC practiced among Dawoodi Bohra Muslims is less invasive than typical circumcision of boys and that, among the Bohra, FGC is a religiously meaningful ritual. This proposal implies that girls should have the same rights to cultural and/or religious identity as circumcised boys. It is a controversial proposal insofar as it directly challenges the central tenet of global campaigns to end FGC, such as target 5.3 in the United Nations Sustainable Development Goal: that girls can only be empowered by protecting them from being subjected to a fear-inducing and painful experience. This issue examines both directions within the equivalence argument: the plausibility of legalization of FGC, but also the possibility that boys require protection from forms of male genital cutting. This second possibility – of proposing an age limit or ban on boy circumcision – is also controversial, particularly at a time in which there is growing concern about anti-Semitism and Islamophobia. This may, in part, explain worldwide reluctance by otherwise interventionist policy makers to act upon the similarities of boy and girl circumcision.

Item Type:
Journal Article
Journal or Publication Title:
Global Discourse
ID Code:
Deposited By:
Deposited On:
07 Jan 2022 16:50
Last Modified:
18 Dec 2023 02:03