Which interventions increase hearing protection behaviors during noisy recreational activities? : A systematic review

Loughran, Michael and Lyons, Stephanie and Plack, Christopher and Armitage, Christopher (2020) Which interventions increase hearing protection behaviors during noisy recreational activities? : A systematic review. BMC Public Health, 20: 1376. ISSN 1471-2458

[thumbnail of Loughran_et_al_systematic_review_accepted_manuscript]
Text (Loughran_et_al_systematic_review_accepted_manuscript)
Loughran_et_al_systematic_review_accepted_manuscript.pdf - Accepted Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.

Download (695kB)


Background Hearing loss and tinnitus are global concerns that can be reduced through hearing protection behaviors (e.g., earplug use). Little is known about the effectiveness of interventions to increase hearing protection use in recreational domains. For the first time we review systematically the effectiveness of such interventions. Methods Systematic searches of nine databases, as well as grey literature and hand-searching, were conducted. Any study design was included if it assessed quantitatively a purposeful attempt to increase hearing protection in recreational settings. Studies were excluded if they assessed noise exposure from occupational sources and headphones/earphones, as these have been reviewed elsewhere. PROSPERO protocol: CRD42018098573. Results Eight studies were retrieved following the screening of 1908 articles. Two pretest-posttest studies detected a small to medium effect (d ≥ 0·3 ≤ 0·5), one a small effect (d ~ =0·2) and two no real effect. Three posttest experimental studies detected small to medium effects (d ≥ 0·3 ≤ 0·5). Studies were rated as “poor quality” and 17 out of a possible 93 behavior change techniques were coded, with the majority targeting the intervention function ‘education’. Conclusions Hearing loss and tinnitus due to recreational noise exposure are major public health concerns yet very few studies have examined preventive interventions. The present systematic review sets the agenda for the future development and testing of evidence-based interventions designed to prevent future hearing loss and tinnitus caused by noise in recreational settings, by recommending systematic approaches to intervention design, and implementation of intervention functions beyond education, such as incentivization, enablement and modeling.

Item Type:
Journal Article
Journal or Publication Title:
BMC Public Health
Uncontrolled Keywords:
?? public health, environmental and occupational health ??
ID Code:
Deposited By:
Deposited On:
13 Oct 2020 14:40
Last Modified:
03 Mar 2024 01:32