Conceptualising Flexibility : Challenging Representations of Time and Society in the Energy Sector

Blue, Stanley and Shove, Elizabeth and Forman, Peter (2020) Conceptualising Flexibility : Challenging Representations of Time and Society in the Energy Sector. Time and Society, 29 (4). pp. 923-944. ISSN 0961-463X

Text (Accepted Manuscript Version. Conceptualising Flexibility. Time and Society. 14.01.20)
Accepted_Manuscript_Version._Conceptualising_Flexibility._Time_and_Society._14.01.20.pdf - Accepted Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.
Download (688kB)

Abstract

There is broad agreement that the need to decarbonise and make better use of renewable and more intermittent sources of power will require increased flexibility in energy systems. However, organisations involved in the energy sector work with very different interpretations of what this might involve. In describing how the notion of flexibility is reified, commodified, and operationalised in sometimes disparate and sometimes connected ways, we show that matters of time and timing are routinely abstracted from the social practices and forms of provision on which the rhythms of supply and demand depend. We argue that these forms of abstraction have the ironic effect of stabilising interpretations of need and demand, and of limiting rather than enabling the emergence of new practices and patterns of demand alongside, and as part of, a radically decarbonised energy system. One way out of this impasse is to conceptualise flexibility as an emergent outcome of the sequencing and synchronisation of social practices. To do so requires a more integrated and historical account of how supply and demand constitute each other and how both are implicated in the temporal organisation of everyday life. It follows that efforts to promote flexibility in the energy sector need to look beyond systems of provision, price, technology, and demand-side management narrowly defined, and instead focus on the social rhythms and the timing of what people do.