Teacher “quality” and attainment grouping:The role of within-school teacher deployment in social and education inequality

Francis, Becky and Hodgen, Jeremy and Craig, Nicole and Taylor, Becky and Archer, Louise and Mazenod, Anna and Tereshchenko, Antonina and Connolly, Paul (2019) Teacher “quality” and attainment grouping:The role of within-school teacher deployment in social and education inequality. Teaching and Teacher Education, 77. pp. 183-192. ISSN 0742-051X

Abstract

Prior research suggests that where pupils are 'tracked', better qualified, more experienced teachers tend to be deployed to higher attainment groups, at the expense of pupils in lower tracks. This is especially pertinent from a social justice perspective, given consistent findings in the UK that pupils from socially-disadvantaged backgrounds are over-represented in low attainment groups. This article draws on data from 380 teachers, drawn from 126 secondary schools in England, and interviews with 118 Year 7 students, to examine whether these findings from prior research in the US and elsewhere extend to the case of England in the present day. Findings show some evidence of these inequitable tendencies: those teachers highly qualified in their taught subject were less likely to be allocated to low sets. We also examine whether an intervention designed to encourage more equitable distribution had any impact on practice, and find tentative evidence that deployment in intervention schools had been impacted in relation to teacher subject qualifications. Pupils believed that teachers of higher sets had higher expectations and standards of behaviour, whereas those for low sets were seen to be unhelpfully indulgent, indicating a need for research attention to pedagogy and tracking. Findings are analysed from a social justice perspective, with interest in the consequences of inequitable distribution of teachers for the reproduction of social inequality.