The protection of traditional knowledge in the Ecuadorian Amazon : A critical ethnography of capital expansion

Moeller, Nina and Oldham, Paul and Szerszynski, Bronislaw (2010) The protection of traditional knowledge in the Ecuadorian Amazon : A critical ethnography of capital expansion. PhD thesis, Lancaster University.

[thumbnail of 2010moeller]
Text (2010moeller)
2010moeller.pdf - Published Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs.

Download (3MB)


This thesis argues that Access and Benefit Sharing (ABS) agreements, no matter how fair and equitable, ultimately help to destroy traditional knowledge rather than protect it. ABS agreements are promoted and implemented as one of the key mechanisms for the protection of traditional knowledge from illegitimate appropriation by pharmaceutical companies or other actors. However, because they dominantly treat traditional knowledge as intellectual property in need of protection from misappropriation, they have the effect of expanding capital into a previously noncapitalist domain. The thesis argues that it is in the domain of subsistence that traditional knowledge is developed and reproduced; but the expansion of capitalism destroys people’s autonomous subsistence and thus the very foundations of traditional knowledge. In order to make this argument, the thesis combines two main strategies. First, a critical understanding of Karl Polanyi’s notion of the double movement of capital is integrated with the autonomist Marxist idea of capital as value practice, and the concomitant understanding that alternative value practices constitute an ‘outside’ of capitalism. This theoretical framework guides discussion of the way in which the protection of traditional knowledge constitutes a form of capital expansion. Second, a detailed ethnographic presentation of a bioprospecting project and its ABS negotiations in the Ecuadorian Amazon is considered in political and historical context. This reveals the way in which traditional knowledge protection introduces market valuations into an area of life which had theretofore been oriented by different values. In conclusion, the thesis points to the importance of engaging in value practices which create and re-create the ‘outside’ of capitalism as a counter-hegemonic form of traditional knowledge protection which actually safeguards the conditions in which traditional knowledge can flourish.

Item Type:
Thesis (PhD)
?? access and benefit sharing,bioprospectingcapitalcritical ethnographydouble movementecuadorindigenous movementnaposubsistence perspectivetraditional knowledgevalue struggle ??
ID Code:
Deposited By:
Deposited On:
14 Nov 2019 14:50
Last Modified:
18 May 2024 02:00