Lancaster EPrints

Blinking Subjects; Blinking Justice? – Law, Medicine and the PVS Patient.

Ost, Suzanne (2001) Blinking Subjects; Blinking Justice? – Law, Medicine and the PVS Patient. Liverpool Law Review, 23 (1). pp. 1-32.

Full text not available from this repository.

Abstract

This paper argues that in medical discourse, there is insufficient unanimity of opinion with regards to the time at which an accurate diagnosis of PVS can be made and that clearly, there is an incomplete medical knowledge of the PVS condition. The judiciary chooses neither to question medical opinion that patients can be considered to be in PVS despite a failure to satisfy the diagnostic criteria, nor medical opinion that patients in ‘near PVS’ will never recover. It is apparent from an examination of the judgements given in PVS cases that the law does not ascribe such individuals with full human status. Such a legal position is particularly problematic in ethical terms when applied in cases involving patients who are in a ‘near PVS’ position, and in the light of evidence that some PVS diagnoses are inaccurate. The application of the best interests test in PVS cases results in the adoption of a paternalistic, objective approach that fails to respect the former competent individuals whom PVS patients once were. If, alternatively, the substituted judgement test were to be adopted, the principle of individual autonomy would become central to the question of whether PVS patients’ treatment should be withdrawn. Furthermore, the application of this test would also ensure that PVS patients continue to be viewed as ‘persons’.

Item Type: Article
Journal or Publication Title: Liverpool Law Review
Uncontrolled Keywords: best interests test ; human status ; individual autonomy ; PVS ; substituted judgement
Subjects: K Law > K Law (General)
Departments: Faculty of Arts & Social Sciences > Law School
ID Code: 25993
Deposited By: Dr Suzanne Ost
Deposited On: 02 Mar 2009 14:19
Refereed?: Yes
Published?: Published
Last Modified: 26 Jul 2012 16:27
Identification Number:
URI: http://eprints.lancs.ac.uk/id/eprint/25993

Actions (login required)

View Item